I am not an expert, but I know what I like. I have come to the conclusion that Whisky producers of Douglas Laing's Provenance Single Cask Single Malt Whiskies know what they are doing, and they are able to produce a quality of whisky that is not possible with large commercial distillers. I have thoroughly enjoyed this offering which is smooth and refined. Of course, you could buy a top premium whisky that was better- but you would have to pay double the price of this nectar.